Report on the 58th
Annual Eastern Snow Conference and joint Snow and Ice sessions with the
Canadian Geophysical Union Hydrology Section and CGU-HS Committee on River Ice
Processes in the Environment
The
study of snow and ice is quite diverse, spanning an examination of sea ice,
frozen ground, snow ecology, glaciology, climatology, snow hydrology, water
management, remote sensing, hydraulic engineering, frozen precipitation and
many other fields. The Eastern Snow Conference
is a venerable organisation of world-wide membership based in Canada and the
United States that is concerned with the origin, precipitation, accumulation,
character, melt and runoff of snow. The
ESC holds an annual conference, alternating between the USA and Canada and from
which it produces a Proceedings and a special issue of Hydrological
Processes. In 1999, the Canadian
Snow Committee of the Canadian Geophysical Union Hydrology Section (CGU-HS)
invited the Eastern Snow Conference for a joint meeting. The Eastern Snow Conference was delighted to
hold its 58th Annual Conference jointly with the CGU this year in
Ottawa. Here with the CGU-HS and
Committee on River Ice Processes in the Environment, and aided by
co-sponsorship from the International Glaciological Society, we have provided
the joint meeting; ‘Snow & Ice: Principles, Processes, Management and
Use’. This year marks two decades since
the publication of the Handbook of Snow, Principles, Processes, Management
and Use edited by Don Gray and Dave Male, and it seemed appropriate to
gauge the progress in snow and ice science since the first printing of that
comprehensive text with a meeting of a similar theme.
The
Ottawa meeting may be judged an example of success from synergy, in that the
joint Snow & Ice meeting exceeded the simple sum of normal ESC, CGU-HS
snow/ice and CRIPE meetings. This
year’s Eastern Snow Conference sessions contained 73 oral presentations and 34
poster presentations, filling three days.
ESC papers were drawn from across eastern and western Canada and USA (including
Alaska), Japan, England, Wales, Norway and Switzerland. For the first time, the ESC and CGU-HS held
concurrent sessions in order to accommodate the number of oral presentations. For the first time, the ESC hosted over 100
presentations. Amongst the various
groups presenting snow and ice papers in Ottawa (ESC, HS, CRIPE, the CGU
Climate System History & Dynamics session and the CGU President’s Plenary
Session) there were over 150 presentations – likely to have made Ottawa 2001
the largest broadly-based snow and ice science meeting anywhere this year.
The
joint meeting opened Tuesday morning with a joint session between ESC, HS and
CRIPE on ‘Cold Season Hydrology: from Freezeup to Breakup’ chaired by Raymond
Bourdages and Mike Ferrick. The session
contained papers describing river flow surges during breakup, hydrological
models for snowmelt and breakup, ice thermodynamics, streamflow and ice-cover
climatology and the use of remote sensing.
Tuesday afternoon began with ‘Snow and Ice Hydrology’ chaired by Phil
Marsh and containing papers on glacier hydrology and hydrochemistry. The second session that afternoon, ‘Snow and
Ice Hydrometeorology’ chaired by Mary Albert dealt with snow water equivalent,
its estimation, extent and depletion.
Wednesday morning hosted concurrent sessions. ‘Frozen Ground’ and ‘Snow and Ice Hydrology’ were chaired by
Chris Burn and Toni Lewkowicz with a range of papers from ground temperature
estimation, to permafrost degradation, frozen soil energy balance, snowmelt/infiltration
over frozen soils and snowpack state as influence by physiography. The ‘Cryosphere’ session chaired by Dorothy
Hall and Dave Barber included papers on detecting and understanding ablation of
snow water equivalent on sea ice and sea ice itself, using MODIS to detect snow
properties, imaging of snowpacks, snow data products and blowing snow
modelling. Wednesday afternoon the
‘Arctic Glaciers Workshop’ chaired by Julian Dowdeswell examined these systems
from ice mass dynamics, to hydrology, ablation, remote sensing, ice flow and
runoff chemistry. ‘Snow and Ice
Hydrometeorology’ resumed Thursday morning, chaired by Kate Brubaker and Ross
Brown with papers on Arctic meteorology, snowfall distribution and measurement,
snow/ice mass balance, distribution, energy balance and ablation, and snow
climatology. Thursday afternoon resumed
concurrent sessions with ‘Snow and Ice Processes’ chaired by Janet Hardy and
Scott Munro with papers on snow structure and gas diffusion, melt processes,
flash, electrical and freezing processes related to ice-covered insulators,
glacial ice dynamics and glacial weathering.
A session from the ICSI Snow-Vegetation Interactions Working Group ‘Snow
Vegetation Interactions’ chaired by John Pomeroy included papers on snow
science and forest planning, remote sensing of snow in forests, and modelling
snowmelt energy in terrain of varying vegetation. These oral papers were complemented by an excellent set of poster
papers presented Wednesday and Thursday in sessions chaired by Andrew Klein and
Dorothy Hall and covering the topics previously mentioned as well as snow
ecology and human perceptions of snow.
The authors and session chairs are thanked for keeping the sessions
running smoothly and lively.
The
31 (at least) student papers showed the health and vigour of this meeting. A number of students prepared papers to a
set format that were evaluated before the Conference by a judging panel chaired
by Andrew Klein. The submissions were
strong and all are to be congratulated on their progress and commitment to snow
and ice. The winner of the ESC Weisnet
Medal was Changiz Tavakoli of the Département des Sciences Appliquées,
Université du Québec à Chicoutimi (UQAC), Chicoutimi, Québec for the paper
‘Dynamic Modelling of Flashover Process on Ice-covered Insulator Surface’ with
co-authors I Fofana and M Farzaneh.
Congratulations to Changiz and his co-authors for superior research.
Two
participants at the meeting deserve special mention. Professor Julian Dowdeswell, Director of the Bristol Glaciology
Centre, University of Bristol, UK was not only the ESC Invited Speaker, but
Chair of the Arctic Glaciers Working Session and moderator of the discussion at
the conclusion of that session. He
delivered the talk; Arctic Ice Masses: Past and Present Form and Flow,
which included thought provoking new research from the Circumpolar Arctic to
stimulate the Working Session.
Professor Peter Adams, MP, a snow hydrologist, glaciologist and former
ESC President, kindly but directly contributed some salient comments about the
future of polar research in Canada to the Arctic Glacier Workshop and then
provided an extremely insightful Banquet Speech on the prospects for our
sciences and what must be done to promote them from the perspective of
Parliament Hill in Ottawa.
Finally,
what progress has there been made in the 20 years since the Handbook of Snow? Those who attended the meeting must judge
for themselves but here is one observer’s perspective. 20 years ago the physical basis for most
major snow and ice processes was outlined but the interaction of these
processes with the environment was not well understood, the sensitivity of
coupled processes to dynamic boundary conditions was not well appreciated, nor
were processes examined beyond the point scale. Though there are still advances in understanding the basics,
these processes are now routinely ‘parameterised’, ‘distributed’, ‘upscaled’
and incorporated in sophisticated hydrological, glaciological and climatological
models. Many current operational
observational techniques were only used for specialist research and the
satellite tools now available (Radarsat, Modis, etc) were in the infancy of
their design, but have progressed over two decades to supplant the traditional
snow survey or glacier mass balance measurements in some instances. The catalyst to larger scale research that
these remote measurements have provided was very evident in Ottawa. While the potential chemical and ecological
significance of snow was recognised and included at the time of the Handbook
of Snow, it was not yet the emphasis of large-scale research and
multi-disciplinary interest that it is now.
The importance of snow and ice feedbacks to the climate system had just
been explored 20 years ago, but now have become the focus for a global
cryospheric science and the basis for critical questions posed to our
community. Some subjects such as snow
on sea ice, and greenhouse gas transport through snow are new contributions to
our meetings. This progress has
occurred during a period when the major national research institutions that
primarily supported and conducted the study of snow and ice have been
redirected and/or diminished and our universities often put under increasing
workloads with reduced resources. The
progress of science in such circumstances is a tribute to those individuals who
have persevered, economised and continued to achieve irrespective of policy
directives or have found new opportunities in the same. From the wide range of subjects being
studied at a high standard, and the dynamic approach of the scientists and
practitioners one can conclude that many of the hopes of the authors and
editors of the Handbook of Snow have been fulfilled, in that the science
of snow and ice has entered a relatively robust, exciting and mature period and
is recognised as a major contributor to geophysics and the earth sciences in
general. As societal interest in the
results of this science increases, we may indeed be on the brink of a period of
unanticipated growth that can contribute to further discoveries and exciting
meetings such as we have just had.
To all, thank you for your contributions to our joint meeting. To the outgoing president of CGU (a former ESC president) Terry Prowse, to the outgoing president of CGU-HS (a snow hydrologist) Hok Woo, and to the programme chairs of CGU-HS, Dan Moore, and of CRIPE, Raymond Bourdages, a great thanks from the Eastern Snow Conference for making this joint meeting a success.
Professor
John Pomeroy, University of Wales, Aberystwyth, UK.
58th
Annual Eastern Snow Conference Programme Chair